Two-Thirds of Software Growth Now Comes From Existing Customers. Retention Just Had Its Worst Year.
Software companies lean on existing customers for most of their growth just as retention weakens. What that means before you bet on a new market.
Matthew Stublefield
6 min read

Sixty-six percent of last year's growth at 300 American software companies came from customers they already had. Over the same year, the median software company's revenue retention dropped further than in any year of the past four.
Those two facts come from different studies, and they belong next to each other. The first is from Teneo's 2026 survey of 300 US software vendors, as CRO Daily reported last month. The second is from Benchmarkit's 2026 benchmarks of 342 B2B software companies, where median gross revenue retention fell from 88% to 84%, the steepest single-year decline in the four years they've tracked it.
Put together, they describe a lot of software companies right now. The growth plan depends on the installed base, and the installed base is leaking faster than it used to. If your own growth has flattened and the board is asking about new markets, that combination is worth understanding before you go looking for new customers.
The installed base is carrying the plan
New customers have gotten harder to win. In Teneo's survey, 80% of vendors said buyers demanded more ROI quantification in sales conversations than they did in 2024, and increased buyer scrutiny was the most-cited constraint on new-logo growth. So companies have leaned on the customers they already have. Vendors ranked protecting renewals as their most important lever for the year, ahead of pricing and ahead of cross-sell and upsell.
That's a reasonable plan. Selling more to people who already know you is usually cheaper than finding someone new. But it moves the risk. When two-thirds of growth depends on existing customers renewing and buying more, the renewal stops being an account-management formality and becomes the most important commercial event of the year.
And the vendors expect it to get harder. They planned renewal price increases of 7.6% on average, while more than half expected more pushback on those increases than last year. Ninety-three percent were worried that customers cutting seats could hurt revenue.
The base is leaking faster
Benchmarkit's numbers show what that pressure looks like when it lands. Gross revenue retention measures how much of last year's recurring revenue you kept from existing customers, before counting any upsell or expansion. The median fell four points, from 88% to 84%. The top quartile fell the same amount, from 95% to 91%, which matters because it means this isn't only weaker companies having a bad year. Benchmarkit calls it a market-level dynamic, which is a polite way of saying nobody gets to sit this one out.
At 84%, the median company loses 16% of its existing revenue every year to churn and downgrades before it sells anything new. Median growth, meanwhile, fell to 20%, the fourth straight year of decline from 30% in 2022.
What's giving customers a reason to cut
Teneo's respondents were specific about the pressure. Seventy-three percent named low-cost alternatives and AI-native entrants as the competitive threat with the biggest impact on their 2025 performance, and they estimated that roughly 20% of deals were lost to low-cost entrants. Thirty-one percent said pricing and negotiation was the sales stage where their performance slipped most.
The people defending renewals are less stable, too. Four out of five vendors said higher go-to-market turnover limited their ability to hit new-logo targets, and an account that loses its rep shortly before renewal effectively has to be re-sold by someone still learning the product.
Every one of those forces gives a customer at renewal a reason to ask for less. A competitor offering most of the value for less money, a seat count that no longer matches how many people actually use the product, a new rep who can't say what the customer got out of last year: none of them are about the product's core idea being wrong, and all of them show up first in the existing base.
Why net retention can look fine while the base leaks
Here's the part that's easy to miss in a board deck. In the same benchmarks, median net revenue retention held at 102%. Net retention counts expansion revenue from existing customers on top of what you kept, so a company can lose a sixth of its base and still report net retention above 100% if the customers who stay buy enough more.
That isn't a problem in itself. Expansion is real revenue. But it means a healthy-looking net retention number can hide a gross retention number that's getting worse, and the two are telling you about different customers. The customers expanding are probably the ones getting the most from your product. The ones leaving or shrinking are telling you something about who it isn't working for, and that information doesn't show up in a blended number.
SaaS Capital's survey of more than 1,000 private software companies shows why it's worth fixing. Growth tracks net retention closely: moving net retention from the 90–100% range to 100–110% was associated with about five more points of growth. The cheapest growth available to most software companies is in keeping and growing the customers they have.
What this means before a new-market bet
When growth flattens, the instinct in a lot of leadership teams is to look outward for the next market. Sometimes that's right. But a new market is the most expensive kind of growth there is, and if your current customers are contracting and leaving faster than they used to, you'd be taking the same product, with the same gaps, to people who know you less well.
I've written about why growth usually comes from the core before it comes from new markets, and about counting the customers you've already lost before you look for new ones. This data adds a third step in the same direction. Before the new market, understand why the existing base is shrinking. A cheap yes leads to an expensive no, and "let's go after a new market" is a cheap yes when the reason your growth slowed is sitting in your own renewal data.
Questions to ask about your own installed base
A few questions will tell you a lot, and most of the data is probably already in your systems.
What's your gross retention, separately from net? If you only track the blended number, pull them apart. A widening gap between them is an early warning that expansion is covering for losses.
Who's contracting, and who's growing? Segment both groups by size, industry, use case, and how they bought. The pattern usually points at a specific kind of customer the product serves well and a specific kind it doesn't. The reasons can be surprising, too. At Adaptavist, when we looked at why customers ended their licenses, documentation turned out to be one of the top five reasons, which no feature roadmap would have told us. I wrote about how that reversed.
What did contracting customers stop using before they cut seats? Seat cuts and downgrades rarely come out of nowhere. Usage usually falls first, and the features that went quiet tell you where the value stopped.
What are buyers asking you to prove at renewal? If 80% of vendors are seeing more demands for ROI evidence, your customers are probably asking you the same thing. Whether you can answer with their own numbers says a lot about whether they'll renew at a higher price.
Would a new market fix any of this? If the reasons customers leave are about the product, a new audience will likely find the same gaps. If they're about fit, the existing base may be telling you which market you're actually good for.
None of these require a new strategy deck. They require looking hard at the customers you already have, while they're still customers, which is a lot cheaper than finding out the same things from a market that doesn't know you yet.
More Field Notes
- Consulting Operations
'300 Million People Is a Big Market on Paper.' Envision's Shutdown Is a Lesson in Market Sizing.
A market sized by everyone with a problem tells you little about a business. Envision's founders said so about their own 300-million-person market.
- Consulting Operations
92% Say Their Research Works. 85% Have Caught It Being Wrong.
Most research professionals trust their research, and most have caught it being wrong. Four checks to run before you build on a finding.
- Consulting Operations
Only 9% of Senior Consulting Alumni Still Work at a Big Firm. Clients Have Noticed.
Senior consulting talent has mostly left the big firms, and clients are buying it directly. What that changes for how a boutique advisor sells.
Want help running a sharper practice?
The reading and synthesis behind your client work, handled – a living deliverable kept current, so more of your time goes where your name is actually on the line.


